Shadows hang over Europe, and therefore the UK-EU summit. There is that of China, the economic threat, Russia, the security threat, and the internal nationalist far-right, in the upcoming French election in particular. Delivery from an essential partnership is thus required, and will happen to a degree. However, both sides are aware this may not be sufficient and are considering something more, in effect considering whether overcoming their weaknesses means once more coming together.
Divorce has not been easy on the UK. Ideas of bestriding the world signing new trade deals ran into precisely the same forces that drove its own exit from the EU, growing insularity as a response to global inter-connectivity. Initially unable to even generate the interest from the US to any sort of mutually beneficial agreement, it now finds itself even worse to be a victim of coercion from traditional allies, raising drug prices because of Trump’s threats, and facing new Made in Europe barriers from the EU threatening the very survival of a UK car industry. Meanwhile growth remains slow notwithstanding a recent set of better figures, and negotiations with the EU never-ending, but now from outside rather than being at the table.
Initially the EU seemed to have fared better, continuing as if all was well with its world, but of late an increasingly panicked policy agenda towards China in the face of rising domestic discontent in Germany and France in particular has revealed this not to be the case. Denouncing core world trade rules and increasing trade barriers against partners is not the logical approach of a trade-reliant economy, while attempting to play power politics against two superpowers looks optimistic at best and more likely foolhardy. Economic security is also increasingly becoming a byword for French-led protectionism that would reduce resilience as well as hampering growth. Overall, there is a sense of loss, of a several-century hegemony passed, with no obvious strategy as to what is next.
Both the UK and EU are of course mature, heavily regulated, socially and environmentally protective, ageing and arguably entitled economies now struggling to make their public finances work. Complaints about China’s subsidies from cheap loans is a reminder that Europe failed to invest when capital was cheap in the 2010s, quantitative easing instead creating asset bubbles and incentivising financial restructuring more than genuine innovation. In an inter-connected world of dominant multinational companies that reduces the value of the single market, this is all creating the crisis for which blaming others is mostly creating false comfort distracting from the difficult adaptations to come even before we consider what Artificial Intelligence will bring.
In which circumstances, the incentives for the UK and EU to work together are obvious. Europe remains the predominant market for UK trade, thus removing recent barriers such as on food and drink, or preventing new ones such as carbon border pricing or Made in Europe, is an obvious priority. For EU industry in turn, the UK is still crucial to many supply chains most obviously in services but equally in the automotive or pharmaceutical sectors. Movement of people to work is important for both sides, even if immigration is also a difficult political issue all round. Meanwhile, the combined market size would at least slightly and temporarily tip the scales vis-a-vis China, as well as potentially re-emphasising the kind of high value add production that is the only way to make the numbers add up.
Complaints from diehard anti-EU campaigners in the UK about rule-taking or financial contributions in this summit package should be easily overcome. Both were after all recognised as essential for the country even during the most hostile Brexit years, such as with regard to data adequacy and participation in Horizon, thus this is more a matter of calibration than principle. However the embarrassment of UK governments about its subsidiary position, which can never be politically stated even by a leader as so-far-bold as Andy Burnham, makes this far more difficult, part of a broader problem that debates about EU relations seem to bring out the worst in its political culture.
Burnham may thus have been naïve as to the initial reaction among colleagues when raising the prospect of the UK rejoining the EU, having missed the worst of the Brexit years in Westminster because he was at the time Mayor of Manchester. Like EU leaders he wants to see reindustrialisation, and the prospect of this being undermined by their actions draws him towards a rejoin position, even if in both cases there are huge difficulties in achieving their aspiration. Public opinion though seems to support him, driven by President Trump demonstrating the fragility of the US alliance and of course Russia’s invasion of Ukraine that is so strongly opposed.
For the EU such a prospect is broadly welcome across the political spectrum, at least as long as it doesn’t bring UK psychodrama back to Brussels. The EU must after all be a continental project. As a leading trio the UK, France, and Germany largely worked well together, the latter two as the emotional heart of integration, UK and Germany in pushing economic modernisation, and France and the UK being closer in political culture. Others such as Poland and Spain now have a more impressive growth story, but there is a fondness for a pre-2016 EU which was felt to work better.
UK accession to the EU could not though be a normal process, just as already it is not for Ukraine for different reasons. Accession is typically one of the Commission’s lesser files, but the future of the entire bloc and continent is arguably at stake in how these two countries could be handled. In line with the general Brussels funk and absence of vision, there seems to have been little concerted thinking about what this could mean, or how it could happen. In both cases, halfway houses though seem unlikely to work, and special deals unlikely to be negotiable. Security must also be central to whatever happens.
Whether the UK and EU can between them rethink what renewed integration can deliver sufficient to overcome inevitable minor difficulties seems currently rather questionable. Politics across Europe is increasingly driven by nostalgia for a time that cannot return, with the Draghi and Letta reports focusing on the former glories of the single market, and perhaps even rejoin discussions are prone to this. Too many in the bloc are inclined not to think too deeply about the UK or what process would be needed. A Marine Le Pen Presidency in France would worsen matters, potentially straining both the EU and its relationship with the UK beyond breaking point, further weakening its global investment attraction.
“Stay out” is the name of a new group in the UK that is already focusing on the obvious weak points of rejoining, suggesting this would be a case of the UK paying for the failures of the continent. Once again though, they have no better realistic idea of a country or continent in modern times, which undermined their original Brexit, for when they use a phrase like “shackled to the EU” this is a geographical and historical fact. Yet there is little from their pro-EU counterparts either to show how this can be the basis for renewal, they seem to think the case so obvious it doesn’t need making. Only Burnham is really arguing positively, that world troubles including in the bloc make UK reconsideration and sitting round tables with allies even more valuable.
For the moment, all such UK and EU struggles, and just the hope of something better in the future, means the summit will be a success. Deals will be done, cooperation enhanced, smiles delivered on camera. What happens beyond, how Europe responds to its moment of greatest crisis since 1945, is another story, one that must involve the UK, but also a world now increasingly centred elsewhere. Just muddling through, emphasising nostalgia, and leaving facing the future to business, seems the default for most centrist politicians across Europe. While Andy Burnham has started a UK debate that it isn’t clear he can control or easily reverse, the EU’s obsession with China and nationalist backlash to globalisation is threatening real economic harm. Both sides thus have a shared interest in exploring a different path, however difficult this is likely to prove in upending established thinking.